QUANTIK QIES

Fractional Treasurer vs. Bank Desk vs. Consultancy vs. Quant

Category comparison for companies with currency exposure: independence, cost, speed, quantitative capacity, continuity and conflict of interest.

By Pablo Toro, Founder & Chief Quantitative Strategist, QuantikQI LLC · Updated 2026-10-28

A company with currency or interest-rate exposure in Colombia and Latin America has four ways to get quantitative capacity in its treasury: rely on the bank’s trading desk, hire a large consultancy, bring in an in-house quant, or work with a fractional treasurer. Each solves a different problem. This comparison, written by QuantikQI LLC (Bogotá, Colombia; registered in Delaware), compares categories, not firms, and acknowledges that QuantikQI is an interested party in one of them: the fractional treasurer.

How do the four options compare?

Criterion Fractional treasurer Bank desk Large consultancy In-house quant
Independence High: does not execute or intermediate Low: earns from the execution price Medium to high, depending on the contract High: works only for the company
Monthly cost (category) Variable and bounded: fixed monthly fee No explicit fee: paid through the margin (spread) High: project or team fees High and fixed: payroll and benefits
Response speed Fast: deliverables in days Fast for prices; limited for analysis Slow: depends on staffing the team Fast once integrated
Quantitative capacity Senior, on demand High, but oriented to its own book High, sometimes generic Depends on the profile hired
Continuity Renewable monthly contract Permanent, tied to the commercial relationship Ends with the project Depends on the person staying
Conflict of interest Low: does not sell instruments Structural: sells what it values Possible: may have implementation lines Low
Executes trades No Yes No No

This table is qualitative. It includes no figures because actual costs vary by company, city and scope. Any specific number should be requested as a quote and not taken as a general benchmark.

When does the bank desk make sense?

The bank desk is indispensable for execution: accessing the market, closing the hedge, maintaining credit lines. It is the best option when the company already knows what it wants and only needs a counterparty. Its limit is structural: whoever sells the instrument also values it, so the price offered includes a margin the company cannot always see. That is why the desk is complemented by an independent valuation, not replaced by one.

When does a large consultancy make sense?

It makes sense for broad projects with many fronts and a lot of coordination: redesigning the finance function, structuring a reorganization, implementing a system. Its strength is topic coverage and the ability to mobilize teams. Its limit, for a mid-sized treasury, is that the project model does not fit continuous monthly monitoring of hedges well.

When does an in-house quant make sense?

It makes sense when the exposure is large and complex enough to keep one person busy full time, and the company can sustain the cost and the person’s professional development. It is the option with the deepest knowledge of the business. Its risks are dependence on a single person and the fixed cost, which is paid even in months when there is little to analyze. QuantikQI estimates that this cost does not fit in the income statement of many mid-sized companies, but this is its own estimate and not a market figure.

When does a fractional treasurer make sense?

It makes sense when the company has real exposure, but not enough to justify a full-time position, and needs:

  • An independent second opinion on bank offers.
  • Periodic dossiers for management with quantitative backing.
  • Hedge accounting documentation under IFRS 9 (NIIF 9 in Colombia).
  • A contract that can be left unrenewed if it does not add value.

Its limit is clear: it does not execute, it is not an IMC (Intermediario del Mercado Cambiario) and it depends on the company having a person who receives the analysis and decides.

Can the options be combined?

Yes, and that is the usual setup. A common arrangement: the bank executes, the in-house treasurer decides and presents, the accountant books and the fractional treasurer values and prepares the negotiation. QuantikQI starts from that principle: it replaces no one, it complements. In QuantikQI’s model, the company keeps its relationship with its bank and arrives at each negotiation with a theoretical reference price and its own analysis.

How do you decide?

Three questions help:

  1. Do I need to execute or to understand? To execute, the bank. To understand and validate, an independent valuation.
  2. Is it a project or ongoing monitoring? A broad project, a consultancy. Monthly monitoring, a fractional treasurer or an in-house quant.
  3. Does my exposure keep one person busy full time? If so, an in-house quant. If not, a fraction of someone’s time.

To learn about the service and its plans, see fractional treasurer. To talk to QuantikQI: pablo@quantikqi.com.

QuantikQI LLC operates as an independent financial advisor and is not an IMC (Intermediario del Mercado Cambiario). This comparison is informational and is not investment advice.

Book a 30-minute call →